Substitute Unannounced reentry Legal or Illegal
After pulling out a starter, a coach inserted a sub to bat for this starter. The sub was announced and the substitution was legal. In the 5th inning, the coach decided to re-enter his starter. He did not announce it to the umpire or the home book. The starter that was re-entered was properly placed in the lineup in the same place in the batting order.
The opposing team stated since the re-entered starter was never announced, it was not legal and therefore an out.
After reviewing the rule book(s), all I can find is about a sub entering the game. Basically, what the rule book says is that as long as the substitution is legal, the act of entering the game by the sub, that is all that is needed: Rule 3.1.1.
What about a starter re-entering the game? Does he have to be announced or is the act itself enough of announcement?
He does Not have to be announced- The announcement is a baseball etiquette, but not required. I try to politely tell a coach with this type of complaint to try and let the players win it on the field. Sometimes a coach just forgets to inform you when making a change. Mike

Recent comments
8 hours 16 min ago
21 hours 1 min ago
23 hours 28 min ago
1 day 16 hours ago
1 week 19 hours ago
5 weeks 5 days ago
5 weeks 6 days ago
11 weeks 5 days ago
12 weeks 5 days ago
13 weeks 4 days ago